Budget 17.0 – updating my budget for 2017

"I have a plan so cunning, you could put a tail on it and call it a weasel." Lord Blackadder.

Alright so it’s not really up there with one of Lord Blackadder’s dastardly schemes. But my plan is to renumber my future budgets so that I can easily tell which year each one is for. For 2017 I’m going to call it version 17.0 which shares the same number as the year. Cunning or what? I may need to modify it in six months, in which case it’ll be revised to 17.5.

Last year’s Budget 4.5 was for $3,900 a month. I’m starting 2017 with the projected amount from my Goals for Financial Independence. That means Budget 17.0 will be $3,970 a month, or a 1.79% increase.

$3,970 a month works out to be $47,640 a year which covers most expenses (needs + wants) for Ms. DL and me. The only major expense not covered here is my monthly car lease payment which is paid out of Savings. I don’t mind taking out debt to improve cash-flow but I like to have the money in my Savings to back up the debt. So instead of paying the lease upfront at once, I’m stretching it out with a monthly transfer from my Savings account.

Not your standard budget

I call it a budget, but it’s not a strict implementation. The World Will Not End if I over-spend in a month. That’s because the monthly amount is designed with the expected yearly amount in mind. Let’s take the electricity bill as an example.

I estimate that I’ll pay a total of $1,466 in Electricity bills in 2017, which is $124 a month. Therefore $124 is added to the Electricity category each month.

Now our electricity bill tends to be lower in the summer, than in the winter. In fact, for January next month the bill is $102.90 and for February 2017 it’ll be $122.96.

No, I’ve not invented Time Travel – actual payment of the bills from my bank account is delayed since they’re paid through my credit card.

Anyway, I digress. Lower payments for some of the year build up a credit which is offset by higher payments in the rest of the year. Since I keep several months of living expenses in my bank account, it’s okay for the category to go negative for a while, as it’ll eventually be paid back up, and vice-versa.

I can also shuffle money between categories if I need to. This is a last resort option if I really screwed up the estimate. I prefer to revise the figures in a mid-year Budget revision (due to new property taxes, new insurance premiums etc.).

The amounts in each category are tracked in that great Personal Finance software called Microsoft Excel. I don’t use Quicken for this as I prefer the flexibility Excel provides. Quicken helps me reconcile the numbers in my Excel sheet however.

Covering Additional Expenses

Now come closer and I’ll let you in on a secret…

In any given year, I’ll almost always exceed my budget.

Oh, the Horror! But it happens. For example, this year I’ve had a lot of medical expenses. We repaired our deck. And paid for a tree to be removed in our yard.

Note to Self: No more raking leaves = best return on investment ever!

But any additional expenses come out of my Savings. And each month I Save a total of $1,300 from my pay check ($900 in cash and $400 in VWELX for paying off the mortgage in the future).

Where possible I try to save for large expected expenses. But I have some savings put aside for frivolous things too e.g. a new computer or phone. I can always repurpose that money if something more important comes up. My Savings acts as a kind of Planned Emergency Fund in some respects. It’s one of the reasons that I repurposed my designated Emergency Fund and put it to work in my Income Fund.

But isn’t this all smoke and mirrors … aren’t your real living expenses equal to your monthly budget plus savings?

I get this question all the time! Just kidding, it’s never come up before. I rationalize it the following way.

We currently have a mortgage payment. Eventually we won’t have one. When it’s paid off I’ll keep my Living Expenses the same as before. The $1,200 principal payment then becomes the spare money for rainy-day expenses. Likewise, we won’t always need two cars, so there will be extra savings there.

So, I figure that it’s best to keep track of expenses and allow small cost of living increases based on my personal rate of inflation. It allows me to do all future planning based on a known amount, knowing that some additional money will be freed up in the future.

Whew! That was a lot of typing. Time for some tables!

Expense Categories


Mandatory V4.5 V17.0
Utilities: Electricity 110 124 (+)
Utilities: Water 42 40 (-)
Utilities: Gas 50 50
Utilities: Phone 118 105 (-)
Utilities: Internet 126 126
Medical 50 55 (+)
House: Repair 55 55
House: Property Tax 450 454 (+)
House: Insurance 130 132 (+)
House: Mortgage 1,200 1,200
House: Security 46 42 (-)
House: Improvements 35 35
Groceries 540 570 (+)
Auto: Gas 2 2
Auto: Insurance 287 305 (+)
Auto: License 15 19 (+)
Auto: Repair 4 4
Auto: Assistance 0 0
Tax Withholding 54 54


Discretionary V4.5 V17.0
Ent: Books 3 3
Ent: Music 50 50
Ent: Games 10 10
Ent: Movies 5 5
Clothing 10 10
Subscription: Credit Cards 46 50 (+)
Travel 240 245 (+)
Cash 10 10
Computing 110 110
Immigration 4 4
Dining 52 55 (+)
Fitness 2 2
Gifts 40 40
Spare 4 4

Hopefully the categories are all self-explanatory. They’ve not changed from Budget 4.5 where I described them in more detail.

I broadly categorize everything in one of two groups – Mandatory (aka Needs) and Discretionary (Wants).

Let’s go with the good news first!

This year I expect an overall lower Water Bill as my estimate last year was on the high side. I changed our phone plan to save a bit of money, and replaced ADT’s security service with Digital Life from AT&T.

The internet subscription includes Cable TV and is unchanged. As soon as AT&T’s Direct Now has a DVR function I’ll be cutting the cord. Hopefully they’ll have fixed the issues they’ve been having by then too.

But I’ve increased some categories too.

Our electricity bill looks like it’ll be higher next year judging from this year’s bills.

I’m putting a little more aside for Medical, Property Taxes and Insurance. I won’t know the final amounts until later next year so we’ll have to wait and see for those. We increased our Grocery allowance which includes other house incidentals. Auto Insurance and License increased as well.

I didn’t make too many increases on the discretionary categories. Music went up a bit as we splurged on concerts last year. I switched back to a more expensive credit card this year so the subscription category increased. Finally dining went up a bit so we can have an extra meal or two a year.

And that’s about it. I’ll start out 2017 with these amounts and adjust it if necessary in June for the remainder of the year. I’m very reluctant to change the total amount of $3,970 however since it pushes Financial Independence further away.


Quote of the day

Everyone wants to be thin, but nobody wants to diet. Everyone wants to live long, but few will exercise. Everybody wants money, yet seldom will anyone budget or control their spending.

4 thoughts on “Budget 17.0 – updating my budget for 2017”

  1. Your auto insurance and internet seem a little high don’t they?
    Reducing some spending even if it means a bit of your time can be worth it in the long run for sure. All the best.

    1. Hi BHL,
      Auto insurance is high – most of it is due to living in Michigan, and some of it is having two cars on the policy. I have high deductibles to save costs but still need to find a better deal next year. Internet includes TV but it’s a little high as our 2 year ‘special’ price ended.

      So yes, you’re right, it’s time to get back on the phone and see if they can agree a better price or else shop around.
      Thanks for stopping by!

  2. I do like the idea of having a flexible budget that allows for some leeway around the individual categories month to month. I don’t generally follow a budget but my expenses usually fluctuate month to month within a pretty tight corridor since I have a pretty consistent spending level that doesn’t change much.

    I do agree that the internet looks a bit high. One of the best moves I made in the past few years is to cut the cord entirely and combined a lot of my internet + entertainment budgets into one. I can get internet, movies and tv(netflix+amazon prime+hbo(if you can get a password off a loved one!), books(amazon prime kindle unlimited+library card+overdrive) and music(apple music) for around the same price as your monthly internet budget. It’s not for everyone especially not sports fans(but AT&Ts direct tv now is doing a promo on their 100 channel package that might make that an easier pill to swallow) but it works well for me.

    1. Hi timeinthemarket,
      I find myself using my budget more for planning, than controlling, spending. But it does help reduce discretionary spending as I can see the implications of any potential purchase.

      That’s two votes for reducing internet+TV spending now 🙂 Hopefully I can negotiate something with my current provider. If it were me alone, I’d get rid of the cable TV package entirely. Ms DL likes to DVR a couple of shows on the food channel though and I’ve not found a way to get that functionality through cord-cutting. It looks like Sling are starting a DVR service now though, and AT&T Now will also later this year, so I’ll be keeping an eye on that too.

      Thanks for the suggestions, it’s good advice and some food for thought on how to reduce my bills 🙂
      Best wishes,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.